Small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) are the backbone of the Australian economy, representing a vast and strategically vital segment for banks. Yet, despite their importance, recent research reveals that Australian banks are struggling to differentiate their offerings and retain SME customers in an era of rising digital expectations. The landscape is marked by high satisfaction but low loyalty, a strong shift toward digital channels, and a persistent need for physical branches and cash services. This creates both risks and opportunities for banks operating in an increasingly undifferentiated market.
Australian SMEs report high levels of satisfaction with their business banks—79% are satisfied, and 95% are at least nominally content. However, this satisfaction is not necessarily a reflection of exceptional service or innovation. Instead, it points to a market where most banks offer similar products and experiences, leading to a sense of inertia. In fact, 41% of SMEs perceive no improvement in their banking relationship since the Royal Commission, a figure that rises to 75% among sole traders. This apathy is a warning sign: while banks are meeting basic expectations, they are not inspiring loyalty or providing compelling reasons for SMEs to stay.
Trustworthiness, service quality, and convenience are the top factors shaping SME opinions of their banks. Technology and innovation, by contrast, rank low. This suggests that while digital banking is pervasive, it has not yet become a key differentiator in the eyes of SME customers. The risk for banks is clear: in a market where switching barriers are low and differentiation is minimal, any perceived drop in service—such as a cyber-attack or branch closure—can quickly lead to customer churn. Notably, 60% of SMEs who experienced a cyber-attack found their bank less than completely helpful in the aftermath, highlighting the need for banks to deliver more secure and supportive experiences.
Australian SMEs are embracing digital channels at scale. Across all business sizes, a strong majority prefer digital banking:
Despite this, physical branches remain important. About 20% of SMEs still prefer mostly physical experiences, and even among digital enthusiasts, 59% recognize the importance of branches for certain services. The closure of local branches is a major risk: 54% of SMEs would consider switching banks if their branch closed, and another 28% would stay but be unhappy. In total, 82% are 'at risk' if their local branch disappears.
This tension underscores a key challenge: while digital is the future, banks cannot afford to abandon physical channels. Customer retention is driven by convenience, not deep loyalty, and the loss of personal service is a significant concern for many SMEs. To succeed, banks must recreate the hallmarks of personal service—authenticity, humanity, flexibility, and active listening—within digital channels.
Artificial intelligence (AI) is already playing a role here. 68% of SME customers have used their bank’s chatbot, and 91% found it helpful. AI-driven tools can deliver convenient, accessible experiences at scale, but must be designed to feel personal and responsive, not generic or transactional.
While digital payments are preferred by 78% of SMEs, cash remains a significant part of business operations. Half of SMEs receive more than a quarter of their revenue in cash, and this proportion is even higher among larger businesses. Cash deposits and withdrawals (57%) and ATM services (38%) are the most common reasons for branch visits. More than half of SMEs expect banks to continue offering cash services for at least another decade.
Attitudes toward eliminating cash services are split—51% support, 49% oppose. Interestingly, businesses with higher cash turnover are more likely to prefer digital payments, suggesting that the operational burdens of cash are driving a desire for change. However, the emotional attachment to cash, and the security it represents, remains strong. Banks must therefore maintain cash services as part of an omnichannel strategy, supporting a smooth transition to digital while avoiding reputational damage from removing popular services too soon.
The current state of business banking for Australian SMEs is one of adequate but undifferentiated service. This leaves banks vulnerable to disruption from digital-first challengers and fintechs, who are raising the bar for customer experience and operational agility. The risks are clear:
Yet, the opportunity is equally significant. Banks that can break out of the cycle of sameness and deliver truly differentiated, digitally enabled experiences will be well positioned to capture market share and build lasting loyalty.
To seize the SME digital experience opportunity, Australian banks should focus on three strategic imperatives:
Australian SMEs are ready for a new era of business banking—one that combines the convenience of digital with the reassurance of personal service and the flexibility of omnichannel choice. Banks that act now to differentiate through digital innovation, seamless experiences, and AI-driven service will not only retain their SME customers but also unlock new growth in a market hungry for change.
Publicis Sapient stands ready to help banks translate these insights into action—building strategies, investing ahead of the curve, and delivering innovative experiences that set them apart in the Australian SME market.
To learn more or to book a deep dive session with our financial services experts, contact:
© Publicis Sapient 2024